Casa Toscana keeps a shop and a kitchen under one roof, and the shop came first. The Bottega beside the dining room stocks imported olive oil, aged balsamic, Italian wines, espresso, and pastries — the pantry of a Tuscan household, set down on Main Street in downtown Grimsby. The restaurant grew out of that trade, taking over a heritage house and turning it into a cucina where the culture that fills the shelves also lands on the plate. Casa Toscana means Tuscan house, and the heritage address makes the name close to literal.
The menu reads on two levels. A fixed list carries the dishes regulars come back for: Homemade Lasagna, layered and unhurried; Insalata di Casa Toscana; Tortellini di Melanzane e Ricotta; Milanese di Maiale; Risotto alle Vongole Veraci. Above it hangs a blackboard that turns over with the season. The June board leans filled and green — Tortellacci stuffed with taleggio and spring asparagus, finished with lemon crema and aged balsamic; Lasagna Primavera layered with sautéed spinach, Italian sausage, béchamel, mushrooms, and pecorino romano; wild boar sausage; pickerel with lemon and capers; a blood-orange salad to cut the richer plates. Starters and seconds fill in around the pasta — Carpaccio di Manzo, Branzino alla Griglia from the grill, Scaloppine Piccata. The pasta is made on-site from Altamura durum flour.
Casa Toscana is not just a dining room; the Bottega, imported pantry, Italian wines, and fresh pasta lab make the restaurant feel rooted in a wider Tuscan food culture.
The June blackboard brings seasonal and regional dishes into the meal, from taleggio-filled Tortellacci to wild boar sausage and Lasagna Primavera.
The official About page identifies Luca Vitali and ties the restaurant's Grimsby presence to a business that began with Tuscan olive oil and balsamic traditions.
Casa Toscana feels cultural before the first plate lands: the owner story, Tuscan pantry roots, Bottega, Italian wines, and fresh pasta lab all shape the meal. The menu is not just Italian by category; it keeps pointing back to Tuscany, regional cooking, and a shop-born way of hosting.
The blackboard gives regulars a reason to keep returning. June's board moves through taleggio-stuffed Tortellacci, hand-rolled Spaghetti alla Puttanesca, duck confit, pickerel with lemon-caper butter, wild boar sausage, and Lasagna Primavera, making the menu feel alive month to month.
Homemade Lasagna carries the clearest signature role because Casa Toscana builds a whole Sunday ritual around it. It is served with Insalata di Casa Toscana and Signature Cake as a set meal, giving a familiar dish enough structure to become a reason to plan the visit.
Wine is part of the Casa Toscana ecosystem rather than an afterthought. The Bottega carries Italian bottles not treated as ordinary shelf filler, and the events calendar leans into paired dinners and Big Pan evenings, giving wine-minded diners a clearer reason to linger.
Casa Toscana works well when dinner is planned in advance. The heritage-house setting, reservation flow, Sunday prix fixe, and recurring Big Pan evenings make it feel like a small occasion even when the food stays warmly familiar rather than formal.
Share the nuances of your visit to Casa Toscana in Grimsby — the standout dishes, the room, the service.
Write a review
