Teddy's Sports Bar gives downtown Grimsby a different reason to turn up almost any night of the week. Thursdays and Sunday game days are built around half-price wings; Wednesdays pair a burger with a pint; Fridays bring out fish and prime rib; Tuesdays turn the menu into shareable tapas; Mondays cut the appetizers and pints. A regular treats Teddy's less like a menu than like a weekly calendar — a standing answer for a midweek dinner, a payday splurge, or a Sunday spent under the screens.
The food underneath the specials is classic pub cooking kept specific. Wings are the flagship — crisped and tossed in Teddy's own range of Teddy-Style sauces, sold by the pound and the obvious order on a wing night. The fish and chips arrives in a Labatt 50 beer batter, and the fries are beer-battered too, thick and crisp enough to stand as their own dish rather than a side. Bruteddy Bread takes garlic bread somewhere richer, layering melted cheese and bacon into a shareable starter. Around those anchors sit a buffalo chicken sandwich, a chicken Caesar wrap, nachos, quesadillas, coconut shrimp, and a Tuesday tapas board that breaks the menu into smaller shares — fried pickles, mozza sticks, cheese balls, dumplings, and tater kegs.
Menu Tags
What to order
Tiers reflect how diners actually talk about each dish — Diamond is the rarest. Tap a dish to cast your vote.
Chicken Wings are the strongest menu signal, supported by recurring wing specials and a sauce identity that gives the sports-bar menu a clear first order.
02
Six-Decade Grimsby Continuity
The official timeline and local reporting both frame Teddy's as part of downtown Grimsby's hospitality memory, carried from the Jaskula family era into Simon Duong's ownership.
03
Weekly Specials and Live Music
The room is useful beyond a standard meal: weekly food-and-drink specials, live music, and sports-bar energy give diners specific nights and reasons to go.
Restaurantica Analysis
How the score breaks down
8.8
Uniqueness
8.5/10
Bang For Buck
8/10
Food Quality
8.5/10
Local Reputation
9/10
Popularity Factor
8/10
The Playbook
How to eat at Teddy's Sports Bar
1
Order the Chicken Wings Teddy-Style
Start with Chicken Wings if the group needs one decision that actually defines the room. Teddy's gives the wings the most menu weight, supports them with recurring wing deals, and makes the Teddy-Style sauce lane part of the house identity rather than an afterthought.
2
Start the Group with Bruteddy Bread
Bruteddy Bread is the most specific shareable on the board: garlic bread built up with cheese and bacon, sized for a pub group, and named in a way that belongs to this address. Use it before wings or sandwiches when the crew wants a true starter instead of default fries.
3
Make Friday Fish ’N Chips Night
Fish ’N Chips is the cleanest Friday play because it appears as both a core pub dish and a Friday feature. It keeps the visit in Teddy's comfort-food lane without asking the kitchen to be something other than a sports bar with familiar, dependable plates.
4
Save Thursday for Chicken Wings
Thursday is the wing-night move: half-price wings by the pound for dine-in guests. Go then when Chicken Wings are the point of the visit, and keep Sunday in mind if game-day food and drinks matter more than a quieter pub meal.
5
Arrive Early for Live Music
Teddy's can become a music-and-game-night room, not just a place to eat. For groups, arrive before the live music or busy sports window starts, settle in, and let the meal run through wings, shareables, pints, and the room's social energy.
Key Strengths
What this room does best
8.0
The Neighbourhood Anchor
Teddy's reads first as a Grimsby fixture: the same downtown address carries old tavern history, the Jaskula family's long Teddy's era, and Simon Duong's current ownership into a sports-bar room people still use for familiar pub nights.
8.0
Standout Signature Dish
Chicken Wings carry the order: they are the diamond menu tag, the dish most clearly supported by Teddy-Style sauce identity, and the item recurring through weekly wing-night and game-day programming.
7.5
Live Entertainment & Interactive Dining
The room is built for more than a plate and a pint. Teddy's has current live-music programming, sports-bar energy, and recurring events that make a visit feel like a social night rather than a quiet meal stop.
7.5
Comfort Food Specialists
Teddy's strength is familiar food done in a pub register: wings, Fish ’N Chips, Bruteddy Bread, fries, wraps, sandwiches, nachos, and shareables that make sense for groups, games, and regulars.
7.0
Budget Dining
Value is practical here: half-price wings, half-price appetizers, burger combinations, Friday fish and prime-rib features, Sunday game-day food, and all-day drink offers give regulars several ways to time the visit.
Community Reviews
What diners are saying
No reviews yet
Be the first to weigh in
Share the nuances of your visit to Teddy's Sports Bar in Grimsby — the standout dishes, the room, the service.