The recipes travelled north from a family bistro and gelateria in Northeast Italy, and the kitchen on Main Street still cooks to them. Handmade gnocchi is rolled in house and finished with a choice of meat or rosé sauce. Annie's Famous Lasagna stacks homemade noodles with bechamel and bolognese, and the gelato traces straight back to the gelateria the family once ran. This is Italian cooking treated as inheritance rather than concept: the parents who learned the recipes are still connected to the day-to-day, staples like olive oil and prosciutto are brought in from Italy rather than approximated, and a short list of dishes has been made the same way long enough that the names simply stuck.
The menu is wide enough to reward a second and third visit. The pasta bench runs from Aglio, Olio, Pepperoncino — spaghetti with olive oil, chilli flakes, and garlic — to Frutti di Mare, a seafood linguini loaded with clams, shrimp, scallops, and mussels alongside sundried tomatoes and arugula in white wine and a light tomato sauce. Mushroom Ravioli arrives with sautéed pancetta and sweet Peruvian peppers in cream, while Penne with Sausage Sauce leans spicy against artichoke, sundried tomato, and asparagus. The twelve-inch pizzas split between the meat-stacked Mamma Anna's — Italian sausage, salami, ham, and bacon — the chilli-flecked Diavola, and brighter builds like the Arugula Pesto, finished with goat cheese and a balsamic reduction. The Bianca skips tomato entirely for caramelized onions, mushrooms, pancetta, and provolone. Arancini, the Sicilian-style saffron risotto balls stuffed with mozzarella and parmesan, make the natural opening before any of it.
Menu Tags
What to order
Tiers reflect how diners actually talk about each dish — Diamond is the rarest. Tap a dish to cast your vote.
The restaurant's identity comes from Manny Buttus and family recipes shaped by a Northeast Italy bistro and gelateria background.
02
Pasta-and-Pizza Depth
The menu has enough range for repeat ordering, from lasagna and gnocchi to seafood linguini, risotto-ball starters, panini, and 12-inch pizzas.
03
Useful Beyond Dinner
Walk-in dining, phone takeout, weather-dependent patio seating, and the pickup-only Market Place make it practical for both visitors and locals.
Restaurantica Analysis
How the score breaks down
9.1
Uniqueness
7.5/10
Bang For Buck
8/10
Food Quality
8.5/10
Local Reputation
8.5/10
Popularity Factor
8.5/10
The Playbook
How to eat at That Little Place By The Lights
1
Build Dinner Around Lasagna and Gnocchi
If this is a first visit, make the table feel anchored by pairing Annie's Famous Lasagna with Handmade Gnocchi. One brings the bechamel-and-bolognese comfort lane, while the other shows the kitchen's handmade pasta identity without needing to chase novelty.
2
Start With Arancini Before the Pasta
Use Arancini as the opening move when the table is headed toward heavier pasta. The saffron risotto, mozzarella, parmesan, and tomato sauce make it a compact preview of the kitchen's Italian comfort style before Frutti di Mare or Mushroom Ravioli arrives.
3
Use Mamma Anna's for Group Pizza
For a mixed table, bring one pasta anchor and one pizza anchor instead of ordering only from the pasta side. Mamma Anna's covers the meat-heavy pizza lane, while Arugula Pesto or Diavola lets the group add either a brighter herb-driven pie or a spicier one.
4
Pair the Terrazza With Gelato
When the waterfront patio is open, keep the meal a little lighter and save room for Gelato or Tiramisu. The room's best casual rhythm is pasta, pizza, or a panino first, then a dessert finish that ties back to the family's gelateria roots.
5
Call Ahead for Market Place Meals
The Market Place is most useful when dinner needs to leave the restaurant with you. Call two days ahead for small or family-sized take-home meals, then use Gelato or Tiramisu as the low-effort dessert add-on when pickup timing matters.
Key Strengths
What this room does best
8.0
Comfort Food Specialists
This is a comfort-food Italian room first: lasagna, gnocchi, spaghetti, meatballs, panini, pizza, gelato, and tiramisu all point toward familiar plates made for repeat cravings rather than culinary theatre.
7.0
Budget Dining
The value case comes from practical formats as much as price: lunch panini, pasta plates, phone takeout, and small or family-sized Market Place meals make the restaurant useful on ordinary nights.
7.5
Cultural Experience
Manny Buttus ties the restaurant back to a Northeast Italy bistro and gelateria, with family recipes, imported Italian staples, and parents still connected to the kitchen story.
6.5
Kid & Family Friendly
Familiar pasta, pizza, panini, salads, gelato, and take-home meals make this an easy fit for mixed-age tables, especially when the goal is casual Italian comfort instead of formality.
6.0
Senior-Friendly
The appeal for older diners is a familiar menu, straightforward lunch and dinner hours, comfort-led cooking, and practical takeout or pickup options when a full sit-down meal is not the right fit.
Community Reviews
What diners are saying
No reviews yet
Be the first to weigh in
Share the nuances of your visit to That Little Place By The Lights in Huntsville — the standout dishes, the room, the service.