Three Kretans is named for three actual Cretans. Angelo and Doxa Makrydakis left Crete for Kitchener, raised three sons — Gus, Zack, and Niko — and the Greek dining room they built downtown carries the three of them in its name. The detail does more work than most signage. It tells a diner that the food on Frederick Street comes from one family and one island rather than a generic template, and the kitchen reads that way the moment the plates land: sure of the classics, uninterested in reinventing them, and generous with the kind of portions a family cooks for its own table.
The menu runs straight down the Greek comfort lane. Gyro anchors it — seasoned beef-and-lamb carved into a pita, a lunch plate, or a full dinner — and it is the easiest first read on the kitchen. The Chicken Souvlaki Dinner is the baseline order: marinated chicken breast skewers with Greek salad, rice, roasted lemon potatoes, and tzatziki, a complete plate rather than a lone skewer. Moussaka layers zucchini, eggplant, potato, and ground beef under a bechamel cream sauce, and Avgolemono brings the chicken, rice, and lemon soup that shows a kitchen paying attention to the quiet dishes. The Greek salad is the expected one done properly — tomato, cucumber, onion, Kalamata olives, and feta under a house dressing. Starters lean on the meze: dolmadakia rolled in grape leaf, spanakopita, and a three-dip plate of hummus, htipiti, and tzatziki with grilled pita. Saganaki Opa still arrives flambéed tableside with ouzo for the table that wants a little ceremony, and dessert holds the line — baklava layered with walnuts and honey, or bougatsa, warm custard in crisp filo dusted with cinnamon and icing sugar.
Menu Tags
What to order
Tiers reflect how diners actually talk about each dish — Diamond is the rarest. Tap a dish to cast your vote.
Angelo and Doxa Makrydakis opened Three Kretans in 1996 after immigrating from Crete, and the restaurant's name points back to their three sons. That family origin gives the room a clearer identity than a generic Greek menu with no local story.
02
Pre-Theatre Greek Dinner
The restaurant has a dedicated theatre menu, reservation guidance for show nights, and downtown Kitchener geography that makes timing part of the appeal. It is built for guests who want Greek dinner before a performance without gambling on the clock.
03
Classic Greek Comfort Plates
The strongest menu signals are not obscure: Gyro, Chicken Souvlaki Dinner, Moussaka, Avgolemono Soup, Saganaki Opa, and Baklava. The appeal is a full Greek comfort spread with enough starters, plates, and desserts to build a table around.
Restaurantica Analysis
How the score breaks down
8.8
Uniqueness
8/10
Bang For Buck
8.5/10
Food Quality
9/10
Local Reputation
9/10
Popularity Factor
8/10
The Playbook
How to eat at Three Kretans Greek Restaurant
1
Order Gyro as the Baseline
Gyro is the first calibration order because it shows the kitchen's everyday Greek lane without asking the table to commit to the heaviest dinner plate. It works across lunch, pita, and dinner contexts, so it is also the safest anchor when one person wants a quick meal and another wants a full Greek plate.
2
Add Saganaki Opa to Start
Saganaki Opa is the right first move when the table wants the meal to feel like Greek dinner out, not just takeout on plates. Use it before Chicken Souvlaki Dinner, Gyro, or Moussaka; the order gives the table a shared opening without stealing the role of the mains.
3
Book Early Before the Theatre
The official contact guidance is clear that reservations are strongly recommended around local show nights, and held tables have a defined grace window. If the evening is tied to curtain time, treat the online booking link and the theatre menu as part of the meal plan rather than something to sort out at the door.
4
Build a Table Around Pikilia and Dips
Three Kretans Pikilia and Three Dip Meze are the group-friendly way into the menu because they make the first round shared and Greek without forcing everyone into the same entree. Add Dolmadakia or Spanakopita if the table wants more of the meze side before souvlaki and lamb plates land.
5
Save Room for Baklava
Baklava is the dessert to plan for rather than the afterthought to debate when everyone is full. The best sequence is a shared starter, one classic plate such as Chicken Souvlaki Dinner or Moussaka, and then Baklava if the table wants the meal to finish in the same Greek register it started in.
Key Strengths
What this room does best
8.5
Event Companion Dining
Three Kretans is built for dinner with a clock attached: theatre menu, reservation guidance, and a downtown location that make pre-show timing part of the visit. It is a practical Greek choice when guests want a real meal before the curtain, not a rushed compromise.
8.5
Cultural Experience
The restaurant has a real Greek identity story: Angelo and Doxa Makrydakis came from Crete, opened the restaurant in 1996, and named it for their three sons. That background gives the souvlaki, gyro, dips, and desserts a clearer frame than generic Greek comfort cooking.
8.0
Comfort Food Specialists
The strongest dishes are classic Greek comfort plates: Gyro, Chicken Souvlaki Dinner, Avgolemono Soup, Moussaka, Saganaki Opa, and Baklava. The selection is broad enough for a full group, but its centre of gravity stays with familiar plates that regulars can return to.
7.0
Budget Dining
Lunch plates, pita sandwiches, shared dips, and classic dinners give guests several ways to control spend without leaving the Greek lineup. The value is not a gimmick; it comes from flexible formats for quick lunch, full dinner, or shared starters.
7.5
Group-Friendly
This is an easy place to order communally: Three Kretans Pikilia, Three Dip Meze, Dolmadakia, Spanakopita, Saganaki Opa, and family-style catering all point toward sharing. Groups can start with the meze side, then split into souvlaki, lamb, fish, or vegetarian plates.
Community Reviews
What diners are saying
No reviews yet
Be the first to weigh in
Share the nuances of your visit to Three Kretans Greek Restaurant in Kitchener — the standout dishes, the room, the service.