Rustica Pizza Vino is a downtown Orillia Italian pizzeria built around a wood-fuelled oven, handmade dough, current pasta anchors, patio seating, and a cozy room backed by local producer touches.

Theo's Eatery is a family-owned Orillia dining room with a long Italian-Greek comfort menu, takeout and delivery, and a Tselikis family history in local restaurants. Chicken Parmigiana, Five Cheese Crab Dip, and Baked Lasagna are the safest first-pass orders.