Half the tables at Madoi Sushi never order sushi. The all-you-can-eat dine-in menu anchors a kitchen that reaches well past raw fish — into gamjatang, dolsot bibimbap and kimchi fried rice — so a group that can't agree on dinner can still settle into one downtown Peterborough storefront and each find a plate. That breadth is the point. Madoi is the answer when one person wants a tray of maki, another wants a hot Korean bowl, and a third just wants something fried and familiar. The name carries the same idea: Madoi calls itself a Happy Circle, a place where good friends meet, and the menu is built to seat exactly that kind of table.
The sushi list rewards diners who like to build. Maki Combo B lets a table choose three rolls rather than commit to a chef's tray, and the special maki carry the kitchen's louder ideas: the Fire Dragon stacks avocado, cucumber, crab and shrimp under spicy salmon, then finishes with spicy garlic, unagi sauce, spicy mayo and tempura bits, while the Green Dragon Roll layers shrimp tempura and avocado beneath a sweet soy drizzle. The Madoi Bento Box B is the most useful hot anchor on the menu — one rice or noodle plus two dishes — for the diner who wants sushi-night variety on a fuller plate. Around them sit the smaller Japanese pleasures: Takoyaki, eight deep-fried octopus balls finished with eel sauce and bonito; Okonomiyaki, the savoury pancake over stir-fried vegetables; Sushi Poppers, deep-fried rice with guacamole and a choice of salmon, crab or yam; and a seven-piece tempura plate for the table that wants something hot to start.
Menu Tags
What to order
Tiers reflect how diners actually talk about each dish — Diamond is the rarest. Tap a dish to cast your vote.
Diamond· 2
Gold· 1
On the menu· 13
Key Details
Address
437 George Street North, Peterborough, Ontario, K9H 3R4
Maki combos, build-your-own sushi language and party trays make Madoi easy to order for both solo cravings and multi-person meals.
02
Korean Comfort Alongside Maki
Gamjatang, Dolsot Bibimbap, Kimchi Fried Rice and Chicken Katsu add a warm, hearty lane to a restaurant that still leads with sushi.
03
All-Week Pickup Value
The pickup discount gives takeout diners a simple reason to order directly when sushi combos, bento boxes or party trays are the plan.
Restaurantica Analysis
How the score breaks down
8.3
Uniqueness
8/10
Bang For Buck
9/10
Food Quality
8/10
Local Reputation
8/10
Popularity Factor
8/10
The Playbook
How to eat at Madoi Sushi Restaurant
1
Build Dinner Around Maki Combo B
Use Maki Combo B when the group wants choice without turning dinner into a long negotiation. Three maki rolls give the order enough variety to cover classic, spicy and richer rolls, while still keeping the meal focused on sushi rather than drifting into every section of the menu.
2
Let Madoi Bento Box B Handle Mixed Appetites
Madoi Bento Box B is the practical move for diners who want one composed meal instead of a tray of rolls. The rice-or-noodle base plus two dish choices makes it useful for lunch, takeout and anyone in the group who wants hot food alongside the sushi order.
3
Add Korean Comfort To The Sushi Spread
Do not treat the Korean section as filler. Gamjatang, Dolsot Bibimbap and Kimchi Fried Rice give Madoi a second comfort-food lane, which is especially helpful for groups where not everyone wants a meal made only of rolls and sashimi.
4
Make Fire Dragon The Heat Check
Fire Dragon is the roll to add when the group wants something louder than a standard California or Philadelphia-style choice. Spicy salmon, spicy garlic, unagi sauce, spicy mayo and tempura bits make it a good test of Madoi’s richer special-maki style.
5
Use Party Trays For Low-Friction Groups
For family meals and casual gatherings, the party tray format matters as much as any single roll. Madoi lists sushi, maki and sashimi trays sized for multiple people, so larger orders can stay simple instead of becoming a pile of separate one-off requests.
Key Strengths
What this room does best
8.0
Sushi & Raw Bar
Madoi’s clearest draw is sushi breadth: maki combos, salmon sushi, sashimi, special rolls and party-tray formats all point to a restaurant built around sushi as the main reason to visit. Fire Dragon, Green Dragon Roll and Maki Combo B give the menu specific order anchors rather than a generic roll list.
8.0
Budget Dining
Madoi is useful when diners want sushi value without shrinking the meal. All-you-can-eat dine-in, lunch bento, Maki Combo B, party trays and the pickup discount create several ways to keep a sushi order generous and predictable.
7.5
Group-Friendly
The lineup helps groups whose diners do not all want the same meal. Party trays cover sushi, maki and sashimi, while bento boxes and Korean dishes give the group hot-food options alongside roll-heavy orders.
7.0
Delivery & Takeout Specialists
Madoi separates its dine-in all-you-can-eat identity from a la carte takeout and delivery, which makes off-premise ordering feel intentional. Bento boxes, maki combos, party trays and rice dishes are all practical choices for pickup.
7.0
Adventurous Eaters
Madoi rewards diners who want more than familiar rolls. The same menu that offers sushi combos also has gamjatang, budae jjigae, Dolsot Bibimbap, Kimchi Fried Rice, Takoyaki and Fire Dragon, creating room to explore across Japanese and Korean comfort dishes.
Community Reviews
What diners are saying
No reviews yet
Be the first to weigh in
Share the nuances of your visit to Madoi Sushi Restaurant in Peterborough — the standout dishes, the room, the service.