Rare is filed under steakhouse, but the kitchen's most telling dishes are the ones the label would never predict. Citrus-cured frog legs, confit beef tongue under horseradish and stone-ground mustard, a tartare cut from tenderloin with sprouted mustard and housemade potato chips — the premium cuts are here and they anchor the menu, but the cooking on Brock Street is plainly more interested in range than in the usual downtown steakhouse script. This is chef-led fine dining built for a composed dinner in the centre of Peterborough, the kind of table a group books when the night calls for more than a familiar order.
From the butcher, the cuts run a seven-ounce tenderloin, a ten-ounce New York striploin and a twelve-ounce ribeye, each plated with market vegetables, glace de viande and a choice of pommes puree, confit fingerlings or triple-cooked frites. The Rare Burger makes the same argument in a lower register — an eight-ounce patty ground in house from tenderloin, striploin and ribeye, stacked with parmesan reggiano, tomato jam and pickled onions on a toasted brioche bun. To start, the table can share a cast-iron loaf of housemade French bread with aged balsamic and compound butter, or a farmer platter of cured meats, Canadian cheese and house preserves. Around the beef, the menu keeps reaching outward: roasted bone marrow with confit garlic and grilled baguette, miso-butter charred octopus, five-spiced duck breast with a wild honey gastrique, grilled lemongrass pork loin with bamboo shoots and shiitake, a seared tuna nicoise finished with nuoc cham, and Bay of Fundy salmon over stone-fruit panzanella. Desserts stay in-house, from sticky toffee pudding to a vanilla creme brulee and a chocolate terrine plated under berry sauce.
Andrew Lewin and Mai Dong give the current Rare its narrative shape: a known downtown name carried into a new chef-led chapter rather than a generic steakhouse refresh.
The menu lets butcher cuts sit beside frog legs, tartare, octopus, bone marrow, duck, salmon, and in-house desserts, which gives the room a more interesting center of gravity.
The homepage-backed Saturday prime rib feature gives Rare a clear repeat-visit hook and an easy night-of-week recommendation for diners who want the steakhouse side of the restaurant.
Rare works best as a planned downtown dinner: reservations, polished room, steakhouse mains, desserts, and Saturday prime rib make it a natural pick for anniversaries, birthdays, and slower nights out.
The Rare Burger is not a filler entree; the kitchen grinds tenderloin, striploin, and ribeye in-house, then builds it like a steakhouse dish in burger form.
Andrew Lewin and Mai Dong are part of the restaurant's public identity, and the current menu reads like chef-led stewardship rather than a generic steakhouse list.
The dining room has the right shape for a two-person night out: evening-only dinner service, shareable starters, butcher cuts, desserts, and a room pitched toward warmth rather than volume.
The restaurant actively courts private events with a dedicated contact path, group dining language, and a room sized for smaller celebrations, meetings, and presentation-style gatherings.
Share the nuances of your visit to Rare Restaurant in Peterborough — the standout dishes, the room, the service.
Write a review
