Pennies treats the slider as the whole point, not a bar snack tucked in beside the burgers. The menu is built from small sandwiches — a row of griddled burgers, fried-chicken builds, fish and shrimp — meant to be ordered a few at a time and stacked up with loaded tots and cheap drinks. The canary-yellow bar on Strachan Avenue, along the western edge of Trinity Bellwoods, has run that way since 2018, built for casual rounds rather than formal dinners, where the smartest order is assembled from a handful of small things instead of chosen off a single plate.
The slider list starts at the griddle. The Oklahoma Burger arrives with smashed onions, cheese, pickles and mustard; the Classic Hamburger keeps it to onion, pickles and the same two sauces; the Harlem Chopped Cheese Steak piles ground chuck with iceberg, tomato, onions and mayo. From there it fans out. Fried chicken runs three ways — Southern Honey with coleslaw and hot honey, Nashville Hot dunked spicy with pickles, and Korean with slaw, sesame and a house KFC sauce — before the list keeps going into a Baja fish taco with avocado crema, a Cajun shrimp po' boy, a sausage-and-jalapeño El Paso Melt under Carolina barbecue sauce, and a Beyond Meat veggie build for the table that needs one. Tots carry the sharing: poutine tots under Quebec curds and gravy, supreme tots loaded with queso, sour cream and pico de gallo. Almost nothing on the menu is large, which is the point — it is a list made for grazing.
Menu Tags
What to order
Tiers reflect how diners actually talk about each dish — Diamond is the rarest. Tap a dish to cast your vote.
Pennies builds the meal around small sandwiches instead of treating them as a side category. Burgers, fried chicken, fish, shrimp, veggie builds and tots give the menu enough range for repeat group orders.
02
Weekly Steamies Hook
The AYCE steamies offer gives Pennies a clear timing move beyond the everyday menu. Wednesday all day and Friday after 5 PM are the best windows for diners who want a value-led visit.
03
Group-Night Utility
Late hours, patio energy, private-party booking options and combo formats make the restaurant easy to use for casual groups. It is strongest when the plan is drinks, small bites and a flexible room.
Restaurantica Analysis
How the score breaks down
8.6
Uniqueness
7.5/10
Bang For Buck
9/10
Food Quality
7.5/10
Local Reputation
8/10
Popularity Factor
8.5/10
The Playbook
How to eat at Pennies Bellwoods
1
Start with Southern Honey Fried Chicken
Use Southern Honey Fried Chicken as the first fried-chicken slider because it tells you how Pennies handles crunch, sweetness and slaw in one bite. It also leaves room to add Korean Fried Chicken or Nashville Hot Chicken if the group wants a heat comparison.
2
Add Poutine Tots for the Group
The slider format works best when there is a shared side in the middle, and Poutine Tots are the safest first move. Cheese curds and gravy make the tots feel like part of the meal instead of a filler side.
3
Use Wednesday Steamies with Supreme Tots
The weekly steamies offer is the clearest timing play at Pennies. Wednesday is the all-day value move, while Friday after 5 PM turns the same idea into an early-night group plan; add Supreme Tots if the order needs something shareable beside the steamies.
4
Build a Six-Slider Round
If the group is undecided, lean into the six-slider combo instead of trying to choose one lane. Mix Oklahoma Burger, Harlem Chopped Cheese Steak, Korean Fried Chicken, Baja Fish Taco and Classic Veggie Burger so the order shows the range of the menu.
5
Keep It Late with Classic Hamburger
Pennies makes the most sense when the night is social, flexible and not built around a full formal dinner. The patio, late hours and private-party setup all point toward groups that want drinks, Classic Hamburger, fried-chicken sliders and a room that can stay loose.
Key Strengths
What this room does best
8.0
Burger Authority
Pennies earns this card through a menu that keeps burgers central while still staying playful. Classic Hamburger and Oklahoma Burger give the griddle side a backbone, while the slider format keeps the order flexible for groups.
7.5
Budget Dining
Pennies works when the group wants a full-feeling night without a formal dinner. Sliders, tots, combos and weekly steamies make the order easy to stretch across drinks and shared bites.
7.5
Group-Friendly
Pennies is naturally built for groups: the menu is easy to split, larger parties have clear paths, and tots give the order a shared centre. It works best when the plan is social from the start.
7.5
Late-Night Dining
The late hours matter because the food fits the timing. Sliders and tots can carry a second stop, a post-show order or a loose weekend plan without asking the group to sit through a full dinner arc.
7.0
Patio & Outdoor Dining
The patio gives Pennies its easiest warm-weather use case. Pair the outdoor setup with a slider round, tots and drinks, and the restaurant makes sense as a casual Bellwoods hang rather than a structured meal.
Community Reviews
What diners are saying
No reviews yet
Be the first to weigh in
Share the nuances of your visit to Pennies Bellwoods in Toronto — the standout dishes, the room, the service.