Andrew LeBlanc ran the kitchen at Soho House Toronto before he decided the thing worth building was pizza. Bello Pizza is where that decision landed — a twenty-five-seat shop on Collingwood's First Street, a chef's-kitchen sensibility pointed at a format most people file under takeout. The restaurant's own line is Traditional Values, Not So Traditional Pies, and the menu makes good on the second half: pies named like a crew roster, built on fior di latte and pecorino, finished with hot honey and Calabrian chili. They read less like a pizzeria's checklist than like a kitchen working out how far it can push a circle of dough.
The pizzas carry the visit. Spicy Goat Pizza is the clearest signature — Niagara goat cheese, garlic pesto, Calabrian chili, and hot honey, tangy and sharp and sweet in a single bite. The Bronson is its heavier counterpart, loud with blue cheese, bacon, buffalo-butter sauce, olives, and more hot honey. Between those poles sit Queen Goomba, dense with Italian sausage, double-smoked bacon, and a mushroom melange; Di Rienzo's, stacked with pepperoni, mortadella, soppressata, and fennel sausage; San Diego Surf, which folds oven-roasted pineapple and banana peppers into a pepperoni-and-bacon base; and Super Dave-Ola, soppressata and taggiasca olives lifted with hot honey. For contrast there is the Portabella under truffle cream and pickled chili, and the plain Bello — tomato, basil, and three cheeses — for anyone who wants to see what the dough does on its own.
Menu Tags
What to order
Tiers reflect how diners actually talk about each dish — Diamond is the rarest. Tap a dish to cast your vote.
Bello's strongest identity is a small Collingwood room where pizza is treated as a chef-led dinner format, not just a casual takeout category.
02
Current Menu With Character
Spicy Goat Pizza, The Bronson, Queen Goomba, Di Rienzo's, San Diego Surf, and 3 Peat Vegan give the menu enough personality for repeat ordering.
03
Small-Room Hospitality
The 25-seat setting, reservation guidance, cocktail direction, and events capability make Bello feel more like a planned night out than a simple pizza stop.
Restaurantica Analysis
How the score breaks down
9.9
Uniqueness
9.5/10
Bang For Buck
8.5/10
Food Quality
9.5/10
Local Reputation
9.5/10
Popularity Factor
9/10
The Playbook
How to eat at Bello Pizza
1
Start With Mozza Sticks
Start with Mozza Sticks before the first pizza lands. The banana pepper, pecorino, and spicy asiago combination gives the table a clean read on Bello's style: familiar comfort food, but pushed with sharper Italian-leaning flavour instead of plain bar-snack simplicity.
2
Choose Spicy Goat Pizza for Heat
Choose Spicy Goat Pizza when the table wants the most complete Bello signature in one pie. Niagara goat cheese, garlic pesto, Calabrian chili, and hot honey make it rich, tangy, spicy, and sweet without losing the pizza's comfort-food centre.
3
Make The Bronson the Table Anchor
Make The Bronson the table anchor, especially if you are splitting multiple pizzas. Blue cheese, bacon, buffalo-butter sauce, olives, and hot honey make it bigger and louder than the tomato-led pies, so it works best beside something cleaner like Nines or 3 Peat Vegan.
4
Book the 25-Seat Room Ahead
Book ahead when the night matters. Bello's own guidance says reservations are strongly recommended, and the official history describes the Collingwood shop as an intimate 25-seat room, so a planned dinner is safer than treating it like a casual drop-in pizza stop.
5
Keep 3 Peat Vegan in the Order
Keep 3 Peat Vegan in the order when the table includes plant-based diners or anyone who wants a lighter counterpoint. Tomato, garlic, basil, piquillo peppers, Calabrian chili, and garlic pesto give it enough structure to sit beside the cheese-heavy pies.
Key Strengths
What this room does best
8.5
Epic Pizza
Bello is a pizza-first dining room where the pies carry the visit, from Spicy Goat Pizza and The Bronson to Queen Goomba, Di Rienzo's, and San Diego Surf.
7.5
Date Night Magnet
A 25-seat room, reservation rhythm, cocktails, wine, and shareable pizzas make Bello a natural pick for a planned Collingwood dinner for two.
7.5
Signature Chef Restaurants
Andrew LeBlanc and Mike Trudeau give Bello a named kitchen identity, with pizza craft and hospitality shaping the restaurant's story as much as the room itself.
6.5
Cocktail Program
Cocktails and wine are part of the Bello experience, giving the pizza menu enough polish for a full evening rather than a quick meal.
6.0
Plant-Based Friendly
3 Peat Vegan gives plant-based diners a real pizza choice, while Brussels and Bello Salad add lighter, vegetable-forward options for a more balanced order.
Community Reviews
What diners are saying
No reviews yet
Be the first to weigh in
Share the nuances of your visit to Bello Pizza in Collingwood — the standout dishes, the room, the service.