
Niagara-on-the-Lake Restaurants
Niagara-on-the-Lake Restaurants

Epic Pizza
For restaurants where pizza is a defining reason to go: notable crust, oven style, signature pies, or slice culture strong enough to lead the menu.
Average epic pizza score: 8.2/10
Excellent
BarrelHead
9.2Wood-fired 12-inch pizzas lead the visit, with Bee Sting, Meat Sweats, Green Light, Little Mikey, and other named pies giving BarrelHead a clear reason to be chosen for pizza rather than only for the winery setting.
Bricks & Barley
8.9Woodfired pizza is the main draw, with Burrata Cup and Char, Wild and Blue, Arugula-Prosciutto, Big Mac, Pierogi, Sweet Heat, and classic pepperoni all in play.
Sandtrap Pub & Grill
9.0Pizza is the clearest food identity: the menu runs a full brick oven lineup, and recent review activity still points people toward a build-your-own style pizza night.
The Old Winery Restaurant & Wine Bar
8.8The wood-fired pizza section has a real identity: House Red, Riesling, Sauvignon Blanc, Chardonnay, Pinot, Cabernet, and Gewurtz all build from a four-cheese blend.
Butler's Bar and Grill
8.3The wood-fired pizza side is more than a side note, with Tuscan Pizza, Wild Mushroom Pizza, Arrabiatta Sausage Pizza, Margarita Pizza, Calzone and Meatball Pizza giving the oven real range.
The Grist
9.6The pizza list has enough identity to lead the meal, from MAC-Smash-Za Pizza and Honey That's Spicy Pizza to Black Tie Bacon, Creamy Salmon Bliss, Mambo Italiano, and Goat and Glory.



