The cousins behind The Imperial Tandoor took on a second Peterborough restaurant on George Street North — this time a modern Mexican kitchen and tequila bar, with a name that carries the family's first business forward into a second cuisine. Agave by Imperial sits in downtown Peterborough as a full-service dining room and bar, built around traditional Mexican recipes treated with contemporary technique and a colorful, plated presentation. The kitchen is more ambitious than the strip's casual cantinas, and the bar reads as the central program rather than the supporting cast.
Order strategy for a first visit is straightforward. The Queso Birria Tacos lead the current menu — braised lamb folded with cheese, pickled onions, cilantro, lime, salsa habanero, and a consomme for dipping. The Molcajete de Carnes is the table's sharing move: grilled chorizo, seared beef, grilled chicken, roasted vegetables, cheese, jalapenos, three tortillas, and salsa agave, served in the volcanic-stone bowl the dish takes its name from. Watermelon Ceviche cuts a different note — watermelon with cucumber, cherry tomato, onion, habanero, avocado, and a tostada for crunch. Mexican Street Corn, Guacamole & Chips, and Crispy Coliflor Tacos fill out the antojitos and shareables, and Crispy Fish Tacos sit alongside the chorizo-and-cheese classic on the taco list. Dessert holds at Churros and Tres Leches Cake.
Menu Tags
What to order
Tiers reflect how diners actually talk about each dish — Diamond is the rarest. Tap a dish to cast your vote.
Diamond· 1
Gold· 1
Silver· 4
On the menu· 8
Key Details
Address
376 George Street North, Peterborough, Ontario, K9H 3R3
Agave has current official evidence for birria tacos, molcajetes, ceviche, tacos, churros, margaritas, and other Mexican menu anchors in downtown Peterborough.
02
Family-Run Local Ownership
The ownership story links Agave to Jim Grover, Manish Choudhry, and the Imperial Tandoor team, giving the restaurant a local family-run identity rather than a chain signal.
03
Useful Specials Rhythm
Daily happy hour, Tequila Tuesdays, and all-you-can-eat Taco Thursdays give diners concrete timing reasons to choose Agave for repeat visits.
Restaurantica Analysis
How the score breaks down
9.7
Uniqueness
10/10
Bang For Buck
9/10
Food Quality
9/10
Local Reputation
9/10
Popularity Factor
9/10
The Playbook
How to eat at Agave by Imperial
1
Queso Birria Tacos First Round
Make Queso Birria Tacos the first decision, then add Guacamole & Chips if the group wants a low-friction shared starter before heavier plates. That pairing keeps the opening order focused on Agave's strongest taco evidence without overbuilding the meal.
2
Molcajete de Carnes Group Centerpiece
Use Molcajete de Carnes as the center of a group dinner because it brings multiple proteins, vegetables, tortillas, and salsa into one shared order. It is the clearest way to turn Agave from a taco stop into a full social meal.
3
Guacamole And Ceviche Balance The Spread
Balance richer orders with Guacamole & Chips or Watermelon Ceviche before adding tacos, fajitas, or Molcajete de Carnes. The move works because the menu has both fresh, citrusy plates and heavier cheese or grilled-meat anchors.
4
Happy Hour And Taco Thursday Timing
Time cocktail-led visits around the official daily happy hour windows, or use Thursday when the all-you-can-eat taco special fits the group. The point is not only the discount; it gives a clear reason to choose Agave on a specific weeknight.
5
Margaritas With Churros Finish
If the meal leans into margaritas or tequila, keep Churros in mind as the easy final course instead of ordering only savory plates. It gives the night a simple sweet finish while staying inside the restaurant's current menu evidence.
Key Strengths
What this room does best
8.0
Night Out & Social Dining
A cocktail-friendly Mexican room with birria tacos, margaritas, happy hour, and late service windows that fit downtown social plans.
7.5
Cultural Experience
Mexican dishes, local ownership context, and community coverage make Agave a clear cultural dining pick downtown.
7.5
Group-Friendly
Molcajete, shared starters, taco orders, and weekly specials give groups several easy ways to build a meal together.
7.0
Special Occasion
A lively room, margaritas, and centerpiece dishes such as Molcajete de Carnes make Agave useful for casual celebrations.
7.0
Budget Dining
Daily happy hour and recurring tequila and taco specials give value-minded diners clear windows for a lower-cost visit.
Community Reviews
What diners are saying
No reviews yet
Be the first to weigh in
Share the nuances of your visit to Agave by Imperial in Peterborough — the standout dishes, the room, the service.