Most board-game cafés treat the food as a toll — something to order so the table can keep the games coming. The Boardwalk Lounge cooks like it disagrees. Its Mac and Cheese is built on a roasted-garlic bechamel bound with gouda, aged cheddar, mozzarella, and cream cheese, which is more structure than a game-night bowl needs and exactly the point. The lounge folds a board-game library, a café, a local-drinks bar, a game shop, and a working events calendar into one address on George Street North in downtown Peterborough, and the whole thing runs on a stay-and-play model: pick from more than 650 board, card, and dice games, settle in, and let a visit stretch past the length of a meal.
The kitchen holds a comfort-food lane that suits a long session at the table. The Exploding Chicken gives the sandwich list a sharper edge than the usual café handheld, sitting beside a Roasted Butternut Squash Sandwich, a Grilled Cheese Panini, an Any-time Breakfast Sandwich, and pulled pork. Cheesy Garlic Fingers and Kettle Chips and Dips are the shareable openers, easy to pass around before anyone commits to a fuller order. Vegetarians get real choices here rather than a lone side — the squash sandwich, the grilled cheese, the mac, and the garlic fingers all hold their own. The sweets carry real billing too: chocolate chip, ginger molasses, and oatmeal raisin cookies, popcorn, sundaes, and Kawartha Dairy ice cream, the clean finish for a game that runs longer than expected.
The drinks list reads like a lounge that expects people to stay. Rotating local craft beer sits next to local cider, local wine, and local spirits, with cocktails, café drinks, floats, kombucha, and non-alcoholic beer filling in the gaps so a mixed table rarely has to compromise on the first round. That range is the tell. A place expecting a quick coffee-and-go would not bother stocking for the parent, the designated driver, the cocktail drinker, and the kid ordering a float at the same table. Boardwalk stocks for all of them because it assumes the visit has more than one round in it.
Boardwalk is the work of brothers Dylan and Connor Reinhart, who opened the lounge in downtown Peterborough in 2018; local reporting has followed the pair since as the people behind it. What they built has grown past a café with a shelf of games in the corner. The programming is a real part of the identity — Dungeons & Dragons and role-playing one-shots, a D&D Adventure Camp, trivia, jumbo game rentals, and PTBO Game Designers sessions all run on the calendar rather than sitting as a loose side listing. A shop layer and a newsletter round it out, keeping regulars ahead of what is coming next.
That mix gives downtown Peterborough a recurring reason to gather rather than only to eat. Reservations run through Boardwalk's own booking page, though only a limited block is held back, so walk-ins still work; same-day plans and groups of ten or more are pointed to the phone, and takeout and delivery cover the trips that never make it into the lounge. The practical shape of a visit is easy to read: reserve if the timing matters, start with Cheesy Garlic Fingers while the group argues over which of the 650 games to pull, move to Mac and Cheese or a sandwich when the session settles, and keep a cookie back for the stretch nobody planned for. The game is the reason to come; the kitchen is the reason the afternoon turns into an evening.
Boardwalk's strongest differentiator is the way food and play reinforce each other. The game library gives the visit its shape, while Mac and Cheese, sandwiches, cookies, and shareable snacks make the room feel like dinner rather than a holding pattern.
The drinks list is broad enough for groups with different habits: local beer, cider, wine, spirits, cocktails, cafe drinks, floats, kombucha, and non-alcoholic beer. That flexibility matters in a room where guests are often staying for more than one round.
D&D, trivia, game-design gatherings, camps, rentals, and family programming make Boardwalk more than a cafe with shelves of games. The programming gives Peterborough diners a reason to plan a visit instead of treating the lounge as a quick stop.
Boardwalk is built around play, not just a games shelf in the corner. The game library, role-playing nights, trivia, rentals, and stay-and-play model make the meal an interactive visit from the start.
Groups have a natural path here because the visit has its own activity built in. Reservations, staff-guided game choice, shareable snacks, and a broad drinks list help everyone settle in for more than a quick meal.
The food leans into familiar dishes that make sense during a long game session. Mac and Cheese, sandwiches, garlic fingers, cookies, chips, popcorn, sundaes, and ice cream give the kitchen a clear comfort-food lane.
Boardwalk works for families because the activity gives mixed ages a reason to stay together. The game library, family programming, sweets, sandwiches, and approachable mains make the room easier to navigate than a standard dinner stop.
Boardwalk gives downtown Peterborough a recurring place to gather, not only a place to eat. Game nights, camps, design sessions, parties, local food-and-drink sourcing, and a shop layer keep the lounge tied to repeat community use.
Share the nuances of your visit to The Boardwalk Lounge in Peterborough — the standout dishes, the room, the service.
Write a review
