Restaurantica
Cuisine icon

Windsor Restaurants

Italian Restaurants
Cuisine icon

Windsor Restaurants

Italian Restaurants
1

Osteria Aventino

9.9
Italian · Erie Street Little Italy · $$$

Osteria Aventino is a dinner-led Italian osteria on Erie Street East, built around the La Zingara team's return to the room, regional wine, social dining, and an original wood-burning oven. The strongest public anchors are Valentino, fresh in-house Potato Gnocchi, and wood-burning oven pizza.

2

Vittorio's Trattoria

9.7
Italian · Olde Riverside · $$

Vittorio's Trattoria is a Forest Glade Italian room built around handcrafted pasta, Napoletana-style pizzas, and weekly dine-in offers. Carbonara, Chicken di Vittorio, Nutella Pizza, and lunch panini give the menu enough specificity for repeat visits.

3

Bacchus Ristorante

9.0
Italian · Erie Street Little Italy · $$$

Bacchus Ristorante is a Windsor Little Italy dining room built around current Italian pastas, seafood, steak, wine, and a June specials calendar that makes the polished room useful on weeknights as well as planned dinners.

4

Giovanni Caboto Club

8.9
Italian · Erie Street Little Italy · $$

A public wood-fired pizzeria inside Windsor's century-old Italian club, built around Caboto pizza, parmigiana plates, weekly specials, and a room with real community history.

5

The Cook's Shop

8.8
Italian · Downtown Windsor · $$

The Cook's Shop is a dinner-focused Italian room in historic Windsor, open since 1980 and now led by proprietor Spencer Dawson. Use it for reservation-led evenings built around antipasti, handmade pasta, steak, lamb, seafood, wine, and a low-lit cellar setting.

6

KOMA Restaurant

8.8
Italian · South Windsor · $$

KOMA Restaurant is a chef-owned South Windsor dining room built around Michael Anthony Barlozzari, an intimate reservation-led room, and an Italian-leaning menu that moves from pasta into composed seafood, brisket, and beef tenderloin plates.

7

Terra Cotta Pizzeria

8.4
Italian · Downtown Windsor · $$

Terra Cotta Pizzeria is a Downtown Windsor pizza pick built around wood-fired pies, casual Italian starters, calzones, salads, and delivery-friendly ordering from its Pelissier Street address.

8

Mezzo Ristorante & Lounge

8.4
Italian · Erie Street Little Italy · $$$

Mezzo Ristorante & Lounge is a Via Italia Italian dining room and lounge built around Ahi Tuna, Short Rib, Lobster Penne, Pollo Mezzo, wine, cocktails, takeout boxes, and private-room dining.

9

Vito's Pizzeria

8.3
Italian · Walkerville · $$

Family-owned Windsor Italian built around wood-fired pizza, pasta, antipasti, and a warm Sicilian family story, with Arancini di Riso and Salmone Pizza as the clearest first-order anchors.